Romeos New York Pizza in Duluth
Categories
Location on the map
Duluth, Gwinnett County, Georgia, US
Site: https://romeosnypizza.com/
- Monday:11:30AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Thursday:11:30AM–9PM
- Friday:11:30AM–10PM
- Saturday:11:30AM–10PM
- Sunday:11:30AM–9PM
Romeo’s is my favorite pizza joint in Johns Creek! It’s so good and when my fam comes to visit from Florida they always make it a point to get some Romeo’s to go. Making me hungry writing this review... yum.
Best pizza I’ve had in the Atlanta area. We’ve been here several times and each time has been great.
Cheese pizza , garlic bread , pepperoni pizza , take any item and you won’t leave unhappy. Awesome food and always freshly prepared.
The buffalo wings were good and a decent size. The pizza was just ok though. The pizza is cooked well done, but the cheese wasn’t the best. It was a bit greasy. This place is convenient because it’s next to a movie theatre, so we stopped in.Updated reply to owner: No, the pizza is not for me and we won’t be back. I hope you enjoy your pizza though.
It’s Friday! What better way to celebrate than with a pizza from Romeo’s?!?! They have the absolute best pizza around! The atmosphere is friendly and intimate! The staff is sweet and accommodating! The pizza is amazing! Look at their reviews! I firmly believe that everyone loves Romeo’s! They’re available through takeout! Do yourself a favor! You’ll be so glad that you did!!This is a large meat lover’s pie with extra cheese, peppers, mushrooms, and onions! It’s eight slices of perfection!!
Great little place with legit NY style pizza.ordered carry out and the pizza was perfect
I am the boyfriend of Danielle Harris she posted about this place earlier about how they left our food just sitting on the top of the oven for almost an hour while we sat INSIDE! right in front of their faces. They blatantly could care less about their quality. And Yes I have been on the toilet, throwing up all morning and had to call out of work due to food poisoning from there awful pizza. DO NOT EAT HERE PLEASE!
I’m not a Pizza person and I don’t eat Pizza very often. Last night we got a large Meat Lovers pizza , Vegetarian pizza, Garlic Cheese bread and Jalapeño Poppers from this place and we were happy with the taste, quality and portion sizes of our order. The Meat Lovers pizza had a good amount of meat (Sausage, Ham, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage) and Vegetarian pizza also tasted fine. Both the Garlic bread and Jalapeño Poppers were also good. All in all, I don’t have any reservations in recommending this place if you are looking for a quick bite, dine in or take out.
Very nice pizza. I ordered the Margarita and the Cheese Pizza. They both had a nice crunchy crust. They both had a good amount of sauce, and the cheese pizza had a perfect amount of cheese on it.
The food itself was good, workers seemed alright but almost abrasive. The restaurant is clean and nice though, very convenient for people leaving the Regal Cinemas
Food is great, but service was slow. I was told my order would be ready in 20 minutes for takeout. After arriving at the suggested time, I then had to wait for 30 additional minutes until I asked where my food was and found it it had just been forgotten sitting on top of the oven. Not cool**Update; the wonderful management reached out to me to make things right. I am more than happy to keep returning for some of the best pizza in Atlanta
New York style pies with great taste! Thin, foldable and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Highly recommend for the New York style lovers!
Shame on me been coming here for years. Still this is the best place ever. The owner is amazing she always speaks and makes sure you are taking care of . the staff is amazing and yes of course everything you eat is delicious . cant say anymore about this place. Its just so good
Great pizza and awesome people working here. Reminded me of New York in every way. Lovely place to visit either to dine in or take out. I will certainly visit again and will recommend to family and friends in Atlanta.
Great place for a slice or a whole pie! Good salads, calzones and other pizza joint fare. Great for a quick lunch or dinner.
Very nice place :) greeted kindly at the cashier and food came out looking delicious
Two stars is generous. The XL is probably the size of if not smaller than a normal large. Skimpy on everything - dough, sauce, cheese. It’s like eating a piece of paper. I spent $100 trying to feed a bunch of teens, and the pizza arrived cold and was just nasty. Will never order from this place again.
This place is family owned.And Sharons ability to make everyone welcome is outstanding.Tell her Mitchell sent you.Now to the 🍕.. And food..The pizza is fresh and packs more flavors then most places.( i was in the restaurant bize for 20 plus years and also a chef )Trust me it is worth the visit.
My first time here. I stopped in for a quick slice of cheese & pepperoni (the standard all pizza places are measured by). Romeos was fast and the pizza was good. Great NY style pizza and a great crust. Ill be back for the whole pie. And did I mention they have cannolis? Ill be back for one of those too.
Romeos is the best pizza in Georgia. I visit Romeos every week. The pizza is always good. And the family that owns the restaurant really cares about their customers!
Their pepperoni and sausage slice is one of the best Ive ever had.
World class establishment with some of the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. The lemon pepper wings are a must-get as well!Definitely recommend this spot for a good meal and vibes!
Pizza was amazing, but was even more shocked how good there buffalo hot wings were! As a fellow New Yorker, I highly recommend this establishment.
Not only does Romeo’s have amazing Pizza, but they also have delicious side items. We can’t order pizza without also getting their Mac & Cheese Jalapeño Poppers and wings. The service is phenomenal and the staff is so friendly when you order/pick-up. I highly recommend trying Romeo’s. You won’t be disappointed!!
Once again, our toppings were barely visible. There were two or three mushroom slices and a few onion pieces on each slice. Only one bite of each slice had toppings. Very disappointed. I will pass on this place. I would suggest BYOT!!!
Best pizza by the slice ever!Pizza was done quick, and it was delicious! I want to come back!!!Great customer service when we were there on 7/23/21
Absolutely the best pizza. French fries outstanding. Tried a canolli and I can say having enjoyed canolli throughout the world, this is the best ever! Thanks Romeos. You will see lots more of me.Dan-Johns Creek
I came here last night (11/7) because I knew that it is one of the only places near me that I can buy a single slice of pizza, however I will never be returning back. I walked in and there was not a single mask in sight. Not only did none of the employees have on masks, they also did not have on any gloves...once again...in the middle of a global pandemic. The overall experience was simply so disturbing to me that I didnt even eat my pizza because I felt as though it was unclean.
Good pizza, disappointing service. Ive been here several times before and the service was a lot better in the past. My experience yesterday was bad enough to make me leave a review.The existence of the lunch special seems to be at the whim of whoever is at the register.After I was overcharged at the register, the cashier didnt bother to ask me if I wanted any addons like cheese or pepper or even simple stuff like *NAPKINS* since he was so busy gossiping with the cook the very *second* after pickup.I wont be back. I really, really wanted to like you, but the attitude you have toward your customers is appalling.
I go there often, the food is always good. The owner lady (I think) sometimes is busy and doesnt answer right away or notice youre there even. A lot of times people walk in and no one is at the register and they are sitting at a table. There was also a young man who was making pizzas, rang someone out at the register and then touched a cooked pizza to add more toppings. Havent seen them clean anything so it kinda concerned me. Not too bad to eat, its good for a slice but just the inside people and experience are weird.
Best pizza in the Johns creek area by far!!! Went the other day with my family and Gene the owner was so nice to my kids!!! They deserve a 10 star actually!!! Pizza was deliciousssssss!!!!! Wowwwww!!!!!
My husband and I love this place. Friendly fast service and the food is great!
Pizza was good but didnt really remind me of NY style. Their wings were pretty good too.
I love their pizza, mozzarella sticks and wings. However, in the interests of safety, I hope they insist that all employees wear masks, at least until this pandemic is over. They are one of our favorite local restaurants!
I absolutely adore Romeo’s. Great atmosphere and wonderful people. I live almost two hours away and EVERY TIME I come through this is the only place I want food from, definitely worth that drive. Also, I highly recommend the Margarita Pizza if you are having trouble deciding, though it’s all great. The pizza is fresh and ingredients are great quality. Do yourself a solid and choose Romeo’s.
Awesome service and great food. If you like calzones, youll definitely need to bring an appetite!
We love the pizza and garlic cheese bread. Best pizza in town!! We come here a couple times a week. Food is awesome, but we’re always concerned about about the cleanliness. Today my boyfriend saw him put beef on the pizza with his bare hands... Can management please make some changes? We greatly appreciate it!
First of all, everyone in our family loves their pizza - and that is no easy task, we can field a complete baseball team. Second, the owners and employees are always friendly and welcoming. You just cant go wrong here. Recommend highly.
First time I order from this place and what I get was 3 pizzas with a over cook tomato sauce, that was close to be tomato paste. And the crust was over time into the oven. So this was first and last time like a customer to romeosin responce to the owner, still can come a pick up 2 of the 3 pizzas I ordered.
Went there on a date. Atmosphere is well. There is seating inside and out with plenty of space. The pizza is at a great price for a slice and the small ones are also a good deal. Very convenient location. There is a movie theater nearby and other small stores to venture into.
Weve loved Romeos forever...long time patrons. However last night for the first time, we were disappointed. So disappointed I decided to leave a review. To the new owners, the pizza we received was uncooked with cheap ingredients. Please do better. I wish you guys all the best.
Started following Romeo’s on social media before ever trying their menu. I finally had enough after I saw a post of a pizza with Pepperoni, Onions, black olives and jalapeños. It was amazing! Why no pic? Ate every last bite!
Cook didnt wash hamds or wear gloves while preparing pizza
Having lived in NYC for nearly all our lives (25+ years) my husband and I were in a search to find the perfect NY-style slice that was close to home. This place hits the spot 100%. If anyone says that this isn’t NY-style, they obviously have not lived there or just don’t know what good pizza tastes like. Do yourself a favor. Try it out. There’s a reason it’s always so busy! Love this place!
This is true NY style pizza.. The whole experience I had was amazing. The pizza was so delicious, I am just blown away. The service is just as good, everyone was so helpful and so sweet! This place is honestly my new favorite restaurant. 10/10
Just okay to me. Id say the quality is good and the staff friendly, but this type of crisper crust isnt my style for NY, I prefer a little wish well done.
This place has decent food. It’s good. But not great. When I think of New York style pizza I think of floppy soft bottom pizza, the bottoms on this pizza aren’t super hard but not soft. Also it’s over priced for pizza that’s not as good as the price. Out side of Atlanta Pizza places tend to be alittle over priced than inside the city so it’s understandable. Our service was great and food came out fast!
Thank you for replying to me and I want to say your pizza is absolutely wonderful I miss coming by and getting some slices and a pie on the way home and Joey is the name I use on my review my name is Matt, Sharon I hope youre doing well and a big shout out to you and pizza I miss it. 10stars
We have been faithful customers at Romeo’s since we moved to Johns Creek in 2012. Ordered a pizza tonight for pick-up and was both astonished and disappointed that they are not following public health guidelines. My first Concern was no signage telling customers they were required to wear a mask to enter! That was followed by the realization that no one in the shop was wearing masks. I could understand the pizza cooks not wearing a mask, but there was no excuse for the girl working the counter and interacting with the public for not wearing a mask.Very disappointed in the response of this establishment to public health safety and respect for their customers.We have traveled a little this summer and everywhere we went people were wearing masks and requiring customers to wear masks in order to enter shops, hotels, etc.Very disappointed, we’ll be moving our business to a pizza restaurant who is following guidelines.
I’ve been coming here for the past couple of years. The pizza is always amazing. I highly recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza! The staff is always friendly, and food/ quality never lets me down.
Just got a pepperoni and a meat lovers from here, while Ive never been to new york, I cant say whether its accurately NY Style or not, the pizza is good. The crust is crisp, the slices are large and foldable. Very friendly staff.
Delicious pizza and wings! Im super picky about my hot wings, and these rank up there on the top of my list! Great, local business!
18Mar18..My wife and daughter stopped here after a volleyball tournament. We ordered wings and a meat lovers pizza. The wings were fried hard with sauce on the side. Hot and delicious. The pizza was awesome. The crust was thin and just hard enough. The waitress was on point. We will be back when we are in the area..
🤤 Pizza was soooo good! Definitely returning.
I have to admit, the white cheese pizza is absolutely phenomenal!The wings were ok and the salad too.The staff was very friendly and accommodating!
I used to go to Romeo’s to grab a slice before or after a movie at the Regal. I ordered a whole Pizza there before Thanksgiving and it was GREAT. However, I will not go back as they are clearly an anti mask business establishment.
The best pizza around.... guaranteed. You can taste the quality. Ive tried every pizza joint in the surrounding area and Romeos is superior in every way. From the friendly and inviting atmosphere, to a staff that seems to truly enjoy their jobs. To put it simply, Romeos NY Pizza in Johns Creek is the best.... Hands down. Do yourself a favor and give them a try. You can thank me later.
This is hands down the best pizza I’ve had since moving back to Georgia from New York. Great flavor, better price and even better people. If you’re looking for some authentic, old school NY/NJ pizza, this is the only place to go.
Romeos is a fine establishment that is well ran by a family of stand up individuals. Everything I ordered came out fresh and in a timely manner. I was also treated in a courteous manner during my visit by the staff. I highly recommend this restaurant!
This is the worst pizza I have ever eaten. The service was horrible. We walked in and the girl at the counter on 10/13 was totally unfriendly, acted like we were bothering her. Then the pizza came and to say it was disgusting is an understatement. The crust, which was thin, still managed to be doughy. The vegetables were slimy and the sauce was bitter. Never ever would I go back here.
Not terrible. Pizza slices are what youd expect from the oven. Service was ok. I definitely didnt like the price of a slice but maybe thats bc Im old. Any slice over $3 better have a wow factor. This one did not. So if you want a culinary delight, shop elsewhere. But if you want to shut up the brat you created, treat him to this restaurant. Its perfect for a generation of thankless kids who dont know anything about taste or quality.
The best in Atlanta...no.question. Eating pizza slices like you get in Brooklyn. Sensational. I drive 30 miles for Pizza!!!
Being a new yorker i know great pizza!! Loved it and the salad was perfect. The best is the family atmosphere and a wonderful service! Bring your kids.
I go for every birthday and fathers day plus any other time I can make an excuse. Romeos is the one place that we can go that the entire family truly enjoys. Best pizza around and run by an even better family! Family that Pizzas together stays together!
The sauce is awesome and their cheese sticks are devine and deliciousness, all rolled into one = #Chesseheavan. My family and I love Romeo’s Pizza and the staff is very friendly and a super clean restaurant. When we think Pizza...... we think Romeo’s pizza!!!!! Thank you for amazing, fresh, and most importantly, authentic Italian Pizza! No cook nites are easy!
Best pizza in Georgia and the neighboring states!
Pizza quality here is average or below average, the appetizers such as the Mac n cheese poppers are good hence the 3 stars. In my opinion the chain pizzas have more to offer but this location is close to the movies if you want to grab a bite and go watch.
The taste of that pizza🍕takes me back home (NY). So happy 😊 I found a place with great tasting New York style pizza. Also The staff has great customer service and very friendly.
Lots of places will claim New York pizza but this is the closest that we have found that actually tastes like New Yorks! This is our go-to for pizza in the area!
Love the pizza here. They have this veggie pizza special thats to die for; Very, very flavorful. And you cant go wrong with classic cheese. They even have $6 lunch specials! Service is great: friendly and quick!
Best pizza ever, topping are fresh, wings are delicious, and the mac and and cheese poppers stole the show!
Romeos has been a GO-TO place since I was a kid. I am now graduated from college!! So grateful for this family owned restaurant that has been in Johns Creek for over 10 years. Amazing staff and even BETTER FOOD.
This place has great New York pizza. Perfect spot to go before or after a movie!! Grab a slice or a whole pizza. Their wings and desserts are delicious too!
Mac & cheese bites are a real breakout star. All-time best appetizer. The bites alone are worth the 45 minute drive. Hoping to see them in the grocery store frozen food section soon next to those TGIFs loaded potato skins (close 2nd).
Horrible service and barely had any toppings on the pizza.
Really nice restaurant, it was a smart idea to locate this restaurant next to the theater. Really nice service, the restaurant had a really nice atmosphere. The pizza came really fast and was enormous. Would reccomend if you are trying to get a quick and tasty bite before the movies. Also would reccomend if you just want a decent pizza that is made with passion.
The food is delicious whether it’s salad or pizza or calzones, but the management and attentiveness to customer needs is what really makes this place phenomenal! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a regular pizza place.
The pizza is good. The service is meh. The owner is unfriendly. The price changes every time I go in. It isnt the best pizza in the workd, but it isnt Papa Johns either. I dont not recommend. I just say, dont expect a hello or goodbye for stopping in. And plan on spending between 8 - 11 dollars for the same order depending on who rings you up.
Well Im from NY, and my family and I recently moved here from NY one year ago. I speak to my sister on a daily basis and one of the things that I missed about NY was the food. I told her that there was no good pizza places to eat in Ga. Boy was I wrong. Romeos pizza is like taking a slice of NY and sending it right to Johns Creek Ga. The pizza is great and so are the hot wings. If you live in the neighborhood or just visiting, stop by and have a slice!... Good Job!
The pizza was delicious. Just a little on the expensive side. I will visit again.
Romeos Canton location is one of the worst experiences I have had in recent memory. The food was literally rotten, salad with rotted tomatoes, black mushrooms, and black slime on the lettuce. When brought to the owners attention, he had a what do you want me to do about it response. He was rude, and showed a complete lack of care or concern about the problem. The pizza was undercooked, and the sauce tasted old, thick and just awful. What a shame! This was our first and last purchase at Romeos of Canton, and we will share this with our community as well. when you are in the food industry serving food that is rotten, it is shameful, and potentially dangerous to the health of your customers.
Food was great! We really enjoyed
Great pizza! Very close to NY style! Customer service is awesome. You can dine in or take out. They have delivery.
Amazing experiences at Romeos Pizza. The prices are fantastic and amazing service. Definitely need to go and check them out if you haven’t.
For a $15 cheese pizza they did not put the amount of cheese a real NY pizza has. They are already thin crust so they already save with dough but the topping was cheap. Paid $18 for pepperoni pizza and got minimal cheese and pepperoni. Very budget tasteless. Family from NY said one of the worst NY pizza in Atlanta area. Have to keep hunting for true NY pizza. Cant call urself NY pizza if u want to be budget. Rather pay more for the real thing.
Great Pizza and Calzones - people sure are negative for no reason. I am picky about Pizza because I dont really consider it a meal. This Pizza is good though, a little on the messy side which I prefer at times, great crust, always consistent.
Their food is amazing and it’s family owned! You can often find mrs. romeo working with the staff. Everything is fresh and the salads and pizza are delicious. Love you guys!
I was born and raised in New York, and Romeos reminds me of the neighborhood pizzeria. The food and atmosphere are great!! The service was impeccable with a smile. Truly this is one of my top ten favorite eateries.
Just moved to georgia from NY and stumbled upon Romeos, service was great and pizza was crisp and very flavorful. Closest spot ive found to NY pizza so far. Highley reccomend.
First time here. Pizza and wings were very good. No inside dining but a few tables for outside dining.
I get slices all the time! Good food. Friendly service! Easy on the budget
If I could give zero stars I would. Worst pizza I ever had. So greasy and tasted like cardboard. How it’s even in business is beyond me.
I work in the same plaza, which has MANY places to eat, and everyone at Stretch Zone always picks to eat at Romeos! The food is consistently amazing, the staff takes great care, and it’s a relaxing easy-going environment- with outdoor seating!!
Very good pizza for being in the south. Grew up on NYC pizza and this is as close as you can get outside the area.
Love this place since it first opened...pizza slices great, love their salads...always good. Even their soda fountain is properly calibrated and Coke products taste the way they should!
I have always been a huge fan of Romeo’s since they opened back in 2008. The pizza is delicious and it was always nice seeing friendly faces when you walk in the door!
Romeos Pizza is the BEST NY Style Pizza in Johns Creek, possibly Atlanta.Romeos Signature Salad is also one of the best in Johns Creek/Atlanta.
The service is terrible. I got there at the published open time 11:30(not so early for a restaurant - right?) and was promptly yelled at when I opened the door Were Not open!! I replied ok well what time do you open? The blonde Asian girl said well whenever we get everything ready - try back in 30 minutes. Shocking, Seriously? People can run a business that way??? I mean open whenever you decide. Too many pizza joints inbthe world to waste my time on rude staff who just dont care.
I go to Romeos every Friday night with my family and enjoy the salads and pizza, not to mention their wonderful liquid refreshment selection! They are so friendly - Owners Sharon and Gene are AWESOME ! If you want a good pie you gotta stop by :) Camille and Family Luy you guys !!!
If you know real New York pizza, this is the place for you. Since I have been here I havent found a good place yet. Until now. As close as you can get. Definitely a place to get some pizza. See for yourself.
Nice New York style pizza. One of the few places I know that still sells pizza by the slice. Nice treat if you are craving a thinner style of pizza.
We have supported Romeo’s since moving to Johns Creek. Today we go and realize NONE of the staff is wearing masks. We will no longer patronize them as their commitment to safety and decency is negligent.
Excellent pizza as always. Always quick and very convenient location. Workers are friendly.
One slice of cheese pizza was $3.18 which is is an ok price. The slice was big and it tasted amazing. The customer service was great and very friendly.
They never disappoint in yummy quality food nor service! Theyre a win-win! Im picky about my NY pizza! They nailed it!
I was going to try this place but never have I seen an owner of a business answer back low star reviews in such a low class, childish and sarcastic manner. So unprofessional. If you’re this cocky to criticism there’s no way I’d want to try your restaurant. Good luck because it will catch up to you.
Great pizza slices. Fresh salad. Only 4 stars simply because they charge extra to use a credit card.
One of my worst mistakes is ordering from this restaurant. Very unprofessional and disrespectful. Three hours later and still waiting on my pizza and the restaurant tell nothing but lies.
Absolute and utter joke. They have a neon sign that says “open late slices”. Came out of a movie next door at 9:05 and door was locked. Not letting any more customers in. Apparently late in Johns creek is closes at 9:00pm. How they stay in business next to a movie theater is legitimate question. Don’t expect them to be there much longer with this business model.
This is by far my favorite pizza place of all time. My dad and I go here all the time for lunch before a movie. It’s become our tradition because we love the pizza so much!
Crust was to hard and cheese was dried up. While the party next to me had fresh made pizza. They must have been the owner or something
The food was decent, but I didnt see the sign that they charge a 3.99% convenience fee on all orders unless you pay with cash until I had already paid with my card...what convenience did I pay for? Doubtful well eat here again.
OK pizza, horrible customer service. Girl at register is super rude 😡 Not worth the high price we paid. Will not be back and definitely not recommend it!
Pizza was good, had 1 slice of Supreme and1 Meat Lovers
Love this place. Been coming for years before seeing a movie. Salad and a slice!
This place is really good food. The people was super nice. One person in my party wanted to buy a 2-liter and was told that they couldnt because we were eating in. If we are ever up in the area again then we will come back. Good stuff.
I love Romeos! Their customer service is great and the quality is unmatched. The prices are really good especially for my big family.
Mediocre pizza (not enough cheese or pepperoni), half-assed service, but the place is very clean. I spent over $10 for a slice of pizza, some cheese bread, and a soda. Really? Really? And the staff wasnt even very nice...
AMAZING PIZZA!! always go here before going to a movie at regal. always a pleasant experience and family environment. best ny pizza in town.
This place is so great. A perfect hangout for high schoolers. Love the Mac and cheese tots.
Pizza was awesome! Staff is nice! Will definitely be back. Don’t forget to try the Zeppoles for dessert!!!
Now this is what you call real italian pizza!!!!was in johns creek for a business meeting and we decided to check this little gem out.we got to meet the owner which was a pleasure and he helped us pick out some of the best italian dishes atlanta has to offer!!!!!wish they had a place like this in Oveido FL.7 STAR just for them beeing extra extra nice which you hardly see now days!!!!!
Good taste in 2 slices pizza.waited 30min.got it wrong.waited 10 more.not acceptable. Will drive to Vinnys pizza in Buford next time. See my previous review for Vinnys.
4.5 Star out of 5 Star- Food - 5 Star- Service - 5 Star- Price - 5 Star- Atmosphere - 3 StarOne of the best pizza in this area. Margarita pizza is my favorite. Service and price was great.
Love this pizza. The crust is perfectly thin. Real NY pizza. I get a couple of slices w/ extra cheese. I slice for each hip😇
Food is great and super fast.. but the girl in the front isnt the best at her job. She was on the phone the entire time. I had to wait in line for 10 minutes just to place my order.
Great pizza and even better customer service. Would recommend for anyone
Good food, awful customer service. Both times of visiting the establishment within the last week, the two different girls who served me were incredibly rude. I did not feel welcomed or even treated with the cordiality required of servers. Whoever hires these girls needs to reevaluate.
Took my grands after the movie. Purchased a slice for both, cut down the middle. They had their on toppings and ate it all. Really fresh ingredients, will go back definitely😀
Uber Eats driver: pick up was easy, food smelled good and the guys there are cool.
Good pizza, definitely a friendly staff. Food was worth the cost and take out was good option at time.
Absolutely tasteless pizza. Plain cheese pizza was like I was eating the box. Johnnys NY Pizza is better and thats setting the bar way low.
They are being responsible, their food is still amazing, and their customer service is spot on. They always make me feel special! Thank you!
Pizza by pie or slice. Made to order. Other great menu items!
Daughters 4th grade basketball team just went there to celebrate a championship game. The place was almost empty, but the owner still asked the team to go outside after purchase - apparently no large gatherings allowed - will not be going back there ever
Its some of the best pizza that I have tasted since moving to GA 37 years ago from NY.
The service wasnt too great, but the pizza itself was pretty good. We ordered individual slices and they were good, although according to other reviews, the whole pizza isnt as good, and its overpriced
Excellent food Best pizza I’ve ever had in GA. Friendly employees and owners.
Absolutely love this place wonderful owners and great service! The food is amazing and they’re very attentive but not over bearing. 10/10 would go again
The best pizza in Johns Creek, service is always great and it tastes just like authentic New York style pizza.
The pizza was good but the person that rang me up was rude.
Onion rings were amazing! But the pizza wasn’t the best
My brother and I love this place. Weve visited the restaurant on three occasions and we always receive a fresh and delicious pizza.
Great slice of pizzas and not greasy. Quality ingredients and good atmosphere.
Went to pick up take out. No one was wearing a mask that worked there. So irresponsible. They’ve lost my family’s business.
Good pizza by the slice. The veggie is delicious!
I love Rodeos pizza it is the best I could find in New York Pizza. Takes me back home to New York, for sure.
Being a man from New York , who moved here years ago .. this has been the only place in GA who has that same new style taste
Always fresh and good service 👌
This is the only place my girls want to eat pizza. Awesome stuff! If it’s not Romeo’s then no thank you 🤣
Very good pizza. fresh toppings. one of the best around town!
The pizza is almost as amazing as the family running the business! Will definitely be back!
As long as the pizza is good, Im there!
The calzone here was HUGE! Very tasty pizza. As far as for New York style I would say pretty close.
Truly the worst pizza Ive ever eaten. Took forever to come out. Expensive. The Coke was good...
Staff was friendly and had good service, food was great, slices of pizza are huge, I strongly recommend Romeos !!
Best pizza ever! Closest to New York you can get.
The crust was amazing and they were polite and fast!
Best NY style pizza around, great salads and the owner is really nice! 👍
Late night slices available. Crispy crust just the way I like it! Perfect pizza every time!
Awesome new york style pizza.Recommend trying rhe fried mac and cheese with jalapenos. Mmmmm
I always loved getting pizza here before going to a movie here growing up. Great food!!
Delicious Margarita 2 slice special!The picture was taken after I finished.😁
Great if you like old pizza, reheated with not enough cheese. If you want great pizza try Dagwoods in Norcross.
Very good
Friendly staff and good pizza!
Pleasantly surprised. Not from the area. Would definitely eat here every week if we lived here!
The good food was amazing!!! 10/10 definitely coming back
Freshly made, but everything tasted under seasoned. A little salt would go a long way and make their food top notch
The service was outstanding. Super polite staff! Pizza and Stromboli’s were awesome!
Awesome pizza and salad at dirt cheap prices, and the service is pretty good.
Great pizza!!! I also love the location. Very peaceful.
One of my fav pizza spots in ATL METRO
Great wings, great pizza, service is OK, but overall good experience!
Great pizza for a great price. Perfect lunch spot for weekends.
Really soft and crunchy pizza also really hot you have to wait 10 minutes before you eat it
Best pizza in johns creek BY FAR!! and right next to the movie theatre!
I love there huge pizzas bcuz there is always enough for everyone
Great New York style pizza. The sandwiches are also great
The service was great very friendly ppl would definitely recommend anyone to eat there.
Finally, a true New York pizza place in the ATL.. you wont be disappointed.
Great Pizza, Salad and Wings. Best in Johns Creek!
This place is very over rated. The toppings were thrown on and tasted like they came out of a can.
Decent slice and the service is hit or miss. But the location is great and for the most part this place is enjoyable.
Best NY style pizza, definitely will be back
Great pizza. Almost as good as ours .. 😎
Wonderful place for a date night and very good pizza
This pizza reminds me of my old stomping grounds in the Bronx! Definition of NY Pizza!
Friendly staff with quick response
Total reviews rating 4.3
199 Reviews for Romeos New York Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-10Great pizza here. They are open untill 10pm. They sell by the slice, if you dont want a whole pizza. I bring everyone i know here to eat because its one of the best pizza restaurants in town. For not having a brick oven, the taste is just as good as if they did have a brick oven to cook. Definitely worth trying if you are in the area. Even if you are not in the area its worth the drive for the quality!
Review №2
2021-08-19Took the opportunity to check out Romeo’s New York Pizza. Opted for the Meatball Parmigiana. The restaurant was still patio seating but with the slight breeze it was pleasant. The sandwich was quite delicious and the fries were perfect too. We will have to stop by Romeo’s again soon!
Review №3
2022-03-07Fast, fresh and better toppings and even friendlier service than Fellinis. (They have a chicken topping option 👅👅) I have to grab a whole pie next time Im out this way!
Review №4
2022-05-30Ive been coming to this place since 2010. Ive watched this pizza joint grow and develop. The pizza, salad, sandwiches and other goodies, have always remained consistent in quality and taste. This is a family-owned operation, its what I wish more businesses possessed. Its just so hard to find 360° of quality service, food and atmosphere. Thank you, Romeos Pizza.
Review №5
2022-05-07This is now the second time they have messed up my order. Large Supreme, substitute black olives for mushrooms on half. They put the mushrooms on the same side as the black olives and the pizza is missing half of the cheese.
Review №6
2022-03-15I really love this place. I find most pizza places either overcook or use to much cheese on their pizzas. The crust is also very good. I love their Cesar salad and the wings are great too. Its a lot better than your franchise pizza chains and I love that its family owned.
Review №7
2022-03-27First time here for pizza so not sure what to expect. I asked for a base other than marinara and a white sauce was suggested. It was a great compliment to the anti-vegetarian pizza which was called Meat Lovers. Although order at the counter and delivered to the the table the staff checked on us 3 times to be sure all was okay. Beverages are self served. We will be back.
Review №8
2022-05-18In my experience, the ordering and pickup was fast and ready on time (1 star) and the cheese sticks were good (1 star). However, the pizza, wings, and zeppolos were below par. The crust, cheese, and sauce had minimal flavor. It’s football pizza. The wings were cheap and the sauce was clearly generic. The zeppolos were missing that crisp and had uneven dusting from the sugar powder. Unfortunately, I can’t see myself getting pizza from here again.
Review №9
2022-03-28Me and my boyfriend had put in our order and sat at the bar inside until the pizza was ready. They had us waiting over half an hour for one pie pizza and it would have been longer had I not asked about it because not to our knowledge it was already ready just sitting on top of the oven. No one said anything or called out our name for the order. The lady who had taken our order was just aimlessly doing nothing and didn’t follow up with us. All the staff had seen us sitting there for a while didn’t even ask for an update if we’d been help. On top of all of that my boyfriend got food poisoning from it. NEVER AGAIN!
Review №10
2022-02-20Horrible service, last nightwe got to this place 15 minutes before closing we didnt know that, we ordered and we ask how long for pizza to get ready they said 10 minutes. Theres when we find out that they were about to close. We ask if we could be able to eat our pizza there they said yes. We started eating in a hurry. Five minutes later they asked us to pack our food to go and leave, because they were closed and they have to clean the table. We had to finish our food outside on the cold. We could have gone somewhere else if they had told us we couldnt eat there.